DEAR MISS MANNERS: My husband met a very nice, like-minded neighbor during a walk, and we invited him and his wife over for dinner. Almost from the very beginning of the evening, his wife was very critical and rude and insisted on commenting on our home.
She claimed we had too much clutter, too many gallery walls, that our home was a mess, and on and on. At first, I thought she was referring to another space or someone else’s home because I couldn’t believe my ears. It was not until she directed her comments to me in a way I could no longer ignore that her unbelievable rudeness hit me.
She would not drop it. After the fifth comment about clutter, I questioned her constant negative comments on our beloved space by repeating the last one back to her, sarcastically thanking her for her gratuitous input.
Let me say that our space is a mix of airy and cozy, and, until this woman, it had been complimented by anyone who visited. I pride myself on keeping it clean, tidy and inviting at all times. I was at a loss on how to respond and not stoop to her level of offense.
Why in the world would she or anyone with a modicum of manners and respect do this? What, if anything, could I have said or done to curb her rudeness, if not outright stop it?
GENTLE READER: The situation you describe is not life-threatening, but it is bad, and it is therefore helpful to prioritize your response — to use an etiquette equivalent of the medical concept of triage.
Just as hospitals consider it good form to stop the bleeding before you ruin the furniture, etiquette prioritizes putting a stop to insults before you spoil the evening.
Sarcasm — as you discovered — was not the way to do this.
Miss Manners would have first attempted to change the subject, without initially registering any insult received — which perhaps you did. If that failed, she would have eventually ceased to respond, knowing that the silence would eventually register with the woman’s husband, and with the woman herself shortly after. If the rest of the evening could be made bearable, you could still serve the meal.
If there really was no stopping the comments, then eventually you might have had to pointedly stand up and thank them for coming. Either way, there is no reason to ever invite them back.
As to why your guest felt free to insult you: Do you really care?
