A federal investigation named a Colonial district in Pennsylvania. In Delaware, Christina and Red Clay have written policies on how staff address students at school and what names and pronouns they use when contacting home.
WILMINGTON, Del -The Colonial School District named in a federal student privacy investigation Wednesday is in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania. The U.S. Department of Education’s announcement named no Delaware districts, including the Colonial district based in New Castle.
The inquiry raises a question for Delaware families. When does a school tell parents that a student has asked to use a different name or pronouns? Delaware’s school nondiscrimination regulation leaves that question open. Two New Castle County districts, Christina and Red Clay Consolidated, spell out how staff should address students in class and when they contact home.
What federal officials are investigating
The department’s Student Privacy Policy Office opened investigations into five districts. Along with Colonial in Pennsylvania, it named Eau Claire Area in Wisconsin, Thompson in Colorado, Community Unit School District 300 in Illinois and St. Paul Public Schools in Minnesota. The investigations will determine whether the districts violated federal law. Forth
Federal officials pointed to forms often called gender support plans that ask students which names and pronouns they want to use and whether their families know. The department also raised concerns that some districts keep those plans in separate files that parents may be unable to access. Jessica Lester, a spokesperson for Pennsylvania’s Colonial district, told The Philadelphia Inquirer that the policy had been in place since 2019 and was intended to foster a welcoming school community.
The office is examining two laws. The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, known as FERPA, generally gives parents the right to inspect education records a school maintains about their child. The Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment gives parents rights concerning certain surveys or evaluations that ask students for sensitive information, including consent rights in specified circumstances. Protecting Student Privacy
What Delaware’s regulation says
Delaware’s Regulation 225, amended in April, bars unlawful discrimination in programs that receive approval or financial assistance from or through the state Department of Education. It incorporates protections in the Delaware Equal Accommodations Law, which includes gender identity. The regulation is silent on names, pronouns and parent notification. regulations.delaware.gov
Delaware considered a more specific rule in 2017. The initial proposal would have allowed schools in some circumstances to honor a student’s request to use a different name without notifying parents. WHYY reported that the state received more than 11,000 comments, most opposing that provision. Then-Education Secretary Susan Bunting revised the proposal in June 2018 to require permission from a parent or guardian before granting a minor’s request. The state dropped that version in August after receiving more than 6,000 additional comments. WHYY
What Christina and Red Clay put in writing
Both districts allow students to use names and pronouns at school that reflect their gender identity. When staff contact a parent or guardian, the policies say staff should use the student’s legal name and the pronoun corresponding to the sex assigned at birth, unless the student, parent or guardian has specified otherwise. Both districts keep the student’s legal name in the official permanent record. christinak12.diligent.community
The policies also direct staff to protect private information about a student’s gender identity unless disclosure is legally required or the student authorizes it. Neither published policy describes a gender support plan form. Whether either district uses one remains unconfirmed. christinak12.diligent.community
Christina adopted its policy in 2021 and revised it in June 2023. Red Clay’s board approved its policy by a 4-3 vote in December 2021 after removing a parental approval requirement from an earlier draft. Supporters cited student safety and privacy. Then-board President Cathy Thompson, who voted against the policy, argued that schools should involve parents as much as possible. christinak12.diligent.community
What’s known about other districts
Delaware Public Media reported in May 2024 that Christina and Red Clay were the only two of Delaware’s 19 school districts it found with formal policies on the treatment of transgender and gender-nonconforming students. Current practices across all 19 districts remain unverified. Delaware Public Media
Individual plans have been used elsewhere. Spotlight Delaware reported in April that a Cape Henlopen district lawyer’s letter described a gender support plan reviewed with a middle school student’s teachers and school nurse at the start of the 2018-19 school year. Separately, a Cape Henlopen parent told Delaware Public Media in 2024 that the district suggested a plan for her child and later revised it to include his preferred name and pronouns. Cape Henlopen’s current approach to notifying parents remains unconfirmed. spotlightdelaware.org
In a separate California case, the U.S. Supreme Court in March allowed a lower court injunction to take effect for parents challenging that state’s school gender identity policies while the appeal proceeded. In its interim ruling, the court said the parents were likely to succeed on their religious exercise and due process claims. supremecourt.gov
To Go Box
- Ask your principal or district office what happens when a student requests a different name or pronouns. Ask whether staff notify parents, whether they seek consent and whether the district uses a written support plan.
- To inspect your child’s education records under FERPA, send a written request to the school or district records office. Identify the records you want to see, including any support plan the school maintains for your child. Schools generally must provide access to covered records within 45 days of receiving the request. Federal student records guidance
- Find your district through the Delaware Department of Education’s public school directory. Delaware’s Colonial district office in New Castle can be reached at 302-323-2700. Delaware public school directory · Colonial district contacts
- Parents who believe their federal student privacy rights were violated can find complaint instructions through the U.S. Department of Education. Federal complaint instructions
Delaware LIVE collaborates with a network of professional journalists to cover a diverse range of stories across various fields. Staff Writers include experienced journalists and young professionals. If you have questions, please feel free to contact [email protected] or our publisher, George D. Rotsch, at [email protected]