For a month and a half or two, now-Assistant Sheriff Bryan Peterson and Sheriff Kevin McMahill were roommates, Peterson said in a recent deposition.
The reasons and timing of their cohabitation were unclear in the deposition. But Peterson returned to the Metropolitan Police Department in January 2023 after a previous retirement and a stint at UFC and rose to top positions in the agency.
The problem, a new lawsuit alleges, was that Peterson did not meet Metro’s minimum qualifications for some of the positions he held following his return.
In his elevated role as deputy chief, Peterson was one of several Metro officials tasked with managing the department’s response to a June 11, 2025, protest in downtown Las Vegas where people gathered to oppose the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement tactics.
A protester’s lawsuit, filed Nov. 16, claims Metro did not train Peterson to competently handle his duties, and claims he ordered the use of tear gas in violation of state law and approved pepper ball training revisions that failed to include a law restricting the use of projectiles against protesters.
The suit, filed by attorneys Jared Richards and Stephen Stubbs on behalf of protester Engris Dheming, alleges that the department negligently hired Peterson. The attorneys are using those allegations to underscore their larger argument that Metro mishandled the protest response.
Attempts to reach Peterson for an interview through department spokespeople, his attorneys and publicly listed phone numbers and emails were unsuccessful. McMahill did not agree to an interview, but provided a statement Friday afternoon.
In the emailed statement, the sheriff said he hired Peterson “based on his extensive tactical leadership expertise and proven abilities.”
He said Peterson’s training was “fully certified” by the Nevada Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, an assertion the Las Vegas Review-Journal could not confirm. Under Peterson’s leadership, Metro SWAT officers have used force less frequently, he said.
“Strong, experienced leadership saves lives, and Assistant Sheriff Peterson’s work continues to protect both our officers and the community we serve,” the sheriff added.
Peterson unsure if SWAT training covered pepper ball bans
Stubbs questioned Peterson about his qualifications and handling of the protests during a nearly six-hour deposition filmed Oct. 8. The transcript from the proceeding was filed as an exhibit in the city of Las Vegas’ case against Mariah Stack, a protester who faced unlawful assembly and obstruction charges in connection with the protests.
During the deposition, Stubbs asked Peterson whether he knew the law governing officers’ use of chemical agents.
“I would need to see the NRS,” Peterson replied, referring to the Nevada Revised Statute, according to the transcripts.
The statute in question was updated in 2021. Under it, officers may not fire nonlethal or “less lethal” rounds indiscriminately into a crowd of demonstrators, nor aim them at someone’s head, spine or pelvis unless the person in question poses a threat. Police also must issue orders to disperse before using tear gas. A dispersal order is not necessary if there is an immediate threat of harm or death to a person.
Stubbs said he wanted to test Peterson’s current knowledge and did not immediately allow him to reference the law, the transcripts show.
“I want him to say that he doesn’t know currently and he needs to see the NRS,” Stubbs told Metro attorney Dan McNutt, who joined Peterson for the deposition.
McNutt accused Stubbs of badgering.
“I’m not going to say that,” Peterson said. “I know what you want me to say. I’m not going to say what you want me to say. Let me see the NRS.”
He had previously testified that his job included ensuring that SWAT training covered all relevant Nevada law.
After Stubbs reviewed the statute with Peterson, the attorney asked whether the law was in Metro’s most up-to-date pepper ball training.
“I don’t know if it is,” Peterson responded.
In an email to state legislators, Stubbs complained that Metro was “wholly ignoring” the law on the use of chemical agents. As evidence, he cited Peterson’s deposition answers.
Chief District Judge Andrew Gordon said in a ruling this month that Metro has violated its own policy on the use of pepper balls and created a new protest policy that equated First Amendment-protected activity with lawlessness.
“Metro does not appear to adequately recognize the wrongfulness of the officers’ conduct,” the judge said in an order focused on protester Kathleen Cavalaro’s case that took issue with Metro’s broader policy.
McNutt did not respond to requests for comment.
Metro Assistant General Counsel Michael Dickerson said in a statement that Metro’s protest policy reflected the law and that Stubbs had asked leading questions in his role as an advocate.
He also said the June 11 protests “escalated into a serious public safety crisis” with officers facing violence and suffering injuries.
“Since then, under Assistant Sheriff Peterson’s oversight, LVMPD has responded to more than 300 assemblies, demonstrations, protests, and rallies across Clark County without issuing another dispersal order or using pepper balls at those events,” Dickerson wrote. “That record deserves consideration in any assessment of his leadership and is a credit to him and the officers working to protect both public safety and the right to peaceful assembly.”
Qualifications questioned
Peterson returned to Metro in 2023 when McMahill, who had just been sworn in as sheriff, appointed him director of SWAT and K-9. Peterson said in the deposition the position did not exist before he assumed it.
Peterson had first joined Metro in 1999 and advanced through the ranks, becoming a sergeant in 2015. He retired and became head of security for the UFC in 2017.
Peterson made just over $250,000 as SWAT director, with pay set at the captain level, according to the Transparent Nevada website. He said McMahill promoted him to deputy chief, a command position above captain, and he has since advanced to assistant sheriff. His current salary was not available.
He has never tested for or obtained the rank of lieutenant or captain, which are part of Metro’s traditional rank structure, he testified.
“Would you agree that you did not meet the minimum requirements of deputy chief at the time you were appointed?” Stubbs asked.
McNutt objected, saying that Stubbs had misstated the contents of one exhibit, a 2018 Metro job bulletin.
“I guess,” Peterson said.
He said his close personal relationship with McMahill was not the reason for his appointment.
The job bulletin for deputy chief lists a bachelor’s degree as one of the minimum qualifications. It also required that applicants hold the rank of captain.
The job posting also took applicants with “an appropriate combination of education and experience.”
Peterson received his bachelor’s degree in October from Columbia Southern University, a for-profit online school, according to the registrar. He said in his deposition that he now has a college education.
Described as ‘incredible leader’
Sasha Larkin, a former assistant sheriff who at one point supervised Peterson, offered insight into his rise through the ranks. She said in an interview that he had been highly respected in the department.
“He’s an incredible leader,” Larkin said. “What he did for our SWAT team was extraordinary. … His vision and training gave our team exactly what it needed during a very critical time.”
She later added that Peterson was highly qualified, though she did not know his exact resume.
On the night of the protests, Peterson yelled, “Shoot em! Shoot em! Shoot em! 40s! Gas! Shoot em!” Dheming’s lawsuit against the department said.
Peterson testified that he was among the officers who fired pepper balls at the ground during the protest. Peterson also said he “put his hands on” at least one protester, Kathleen Cavalaro, when he arrested her.
“Due to the totality of everything she was involved in and her advancing toward us not obeying,” he said, “she was arrested for obstructing.”
Stubbs and other attorneys have alleged that Peterson shot Cavalaro in the back and that SWAT officer Mark Eshe also fired pepper balls at her.
Defense attorneys have denied that Eshe shot Cavalaro “directly” and argued that she has previously been inconsistent in her allegations of who shot her. Peterson has denied shooting Cavalaro in the back, according to responses provided by Stubbs.
“Metro disputes that the shot to her back was intentional,” Gordon, the federal judge, wrote in a footnote of a recent ruling. “I have reviewed the videotape, and I find she is likely to succeed in showing that the shot was intentional, retaliatory, and excessive.”
McMahill said in his statement that Metro only uses pepper balls during “riots” and does not target peaceful protesters with them.
In the deposition, Peterson said he fired pepper balls when police were under attack but did not remember shooting anyone with the projectiles. He said his understanding was that Cavalaro was never hit with a pepper ball.
Cavalaro has reached a settlement Peterson, Eshe and Metro, court records indicate.
Stubbs urged caution in scapegoating the assistant sheriff over Metro’s alleged use of excessive force against protesters.
“Am I saying this is all Peterson’s fault?” Stubbs said. “I think the lawsuit is clear that I’m not.”
The attorney noted that the sheriff, an elected official, can appoint anyone he chooses, regardless of qualifications.
“It certainly would be unfair to just harp on (Peterson) when an employer put him in this position, knowing his experience or lack thereof, without giving him the proper training and supervision,” Stubbs said.
Contact Akiya Leggio at aleggio@reviewjournal.com. Contact Noble Brigham at nbrigham@reviewjournal.com.