Three siblings inherited a Wyoming ranch held by their family since 1928, but a dispute over access and a proposed hospital land sale led to a $101,232 damages award against one sister that the state’s top court upheld

Three siblings inherited a Wyoming ranch held by their family since 1928, but a dispute over access and a proposed hospital land sale led to a $101,232 damages award against one sister that the state’s top court upheld
November 22, 2026

LATEST NEWS

Three siblings inherited a Wyoming ranch held by their family since 1928, but a dispute over access and a proposed hospital land sale led to a $101,232 damages award against one sister that the state’s top court upheld


Representative Image (AI-generated) A family property dispute can have consequences beyond disagreements over land access, particularly when a planned development is affected. In Wyoming, a disagreement between three siblings over a family ranch, a shared access road and a proposed hospital project resulted in a six-figure damages award against one sister. The Wyoming Supreme Court upheld the award after finding that her actions had improperly interfered with a proposed land sale.In a November 20, 2026, decision available on Justia, the Wyoming Supreme Court affirmed the Carbon County District Court’s judgment in Davidson v. Schleedlewitz, LLC. The court found that Suellen Davidson had interfered with a business agreement involving her siblings and the Platte Valley Healthcare Project (PVHP), resulting in the cancellation of a proposed property sale.

How a family ranch became the centre of a dispute

The case involved Suellen (Sue) Davidson and her siblings, Charles (Chuck) and Deborah (Deb) Davidson. Their family’s ranch near Saratoga, Wyoming, had remained in the family since 1928, when their grandparents acquired it.The siblings inherited equal interests in the Davidson Ranch. Their father later conveyed the neighbouring Commercial Property to Chuck and Deb, who owned it in equal shares. Following years of disagreements and litigation, Sue purchased the ranch in 2017 and became its sole owner. She retained an easement allowing her to access the property through a road crossing the neighbouring Commercial Property, which Chuck and Deb owned through business entities. Another road providing access had been blocked by logs since 2019, making the easement road the ranch’s only available route.Disagreements developed over Sue’s use of the road, including allegations that she interfered with gates and access arrangements. She also complained that her siblings had obstructed the route with fences, vehicles, snow and other barriers.

How the proposed hospital sale fell apart

In June 2019, PVHP approached Chuck and Deb about purchasing approximately five acres of the Commercial Property to construct a hospital serving the Saratoga region. The siblings agreed to sell the land for $90,000. They later agreed to include another smaller parcel for an additional $36,000, bringing the total proposed sale price to $126,000.However, the property contained existing easement rights, including Sue’s access road. PVHP therefore began discussions with the siblings and other interested parties to relocate the road and address access arrangements. Sue learned about the proposed hospital project in November 2019. In January 2020, she recorded a notice of lis pendens against the Commercial Property in connection with separate litigation involving her siblings. Such a notice alerts potential buyers and other parties that a property is subject to ongoing legal proceedings.PVHP subsequently discovered the notice during a title search and became concerned that it could prevent the sellers from providing clear title. The healthcare project asked Chuck and Deb to resolve the issue within 30 days. Meanwhile, PVHP offered Sue $10,000 for her easement rights and proposed alternative access to the ranch. Sue responded with additional demands, including construction of a new gravel road and other improvements.PVHP never responded to her counteroffer. On April 20, 2020, PVHP informed Chuck that it was abandoning the deal because of concerns about delays caused by the lis pendens and the related litigation. It eventually found another property for the hospital.

Why the Wyoming Supreme Court upheld the $101,232 award

Chuck and Deb subsequently sued Sue for intentional interference with a business expectancy. After a five-day trial, the Carbon County District Court ruled against her, finding that her actions had contributed to the failed hospital sale. It ordered her to pay $101,232 in damages and also required her to pay for relocating the easement road. Sue appealed, arguing that filing the lis pendens was protected by litigation privilege and that the damages award was excessive.The Wyoming Supreme Court rejected her arguments. It held that filing a lis pendens is not absolutely protected from liability for intentional interference with a business expectancy. Instead, a qualified privilege applies when someone acts in good faith to protect a legally recognised interest through appropriate means. The court found that Sue’s conduct did not meet these requirements. It found that Sue knew about the hospital sale, did not disclose the notice during negotiations and used it while seeking additional concessions concerning access to the ranch. It concluded that her conduct improperly contributed to PVHP abandoning the agreement.The justices also upheld the damages calculation. The proposed transactions totalled $126,000, while Chuck and Deb had retained $24,768 in non-refundable deposits. The remaining $101,232 represented the amount they lost when the sale failed. The court found that Sue had not provided evidence of the property’s market value to support reducing the award. It therefore affirmed the full damages amount.The Supreme Court declined to consider her separate challenge to the order requiring her to pay for relocating the easement road because she had raised that issue for the first time on appeal. The November 20, 2026, decision ultimately upheld the district court’s judgment, leaving the $101,232 award against Sue in place.

Share this post:

POLL

Who Will Vote For?

Other

Republican

Democrat

RECENT NEWS

Josh Jacobs' heartbreaking journey from sleeping in a car with his father to buying him a house after achieving NFL success | NFL News

Josh Jacobs’ heartbreaking journey from sleeping in a car with his father to buying him a house after achieving NFL success | NFL News

Two Kansas couples challenged their neighbours' 100-acre fenced deer-hunting operation over safety fears; a November 20 appeals court ruled it is a recreational preserve that needs a special zoning permit

Two Kansas couples challenged their neighbours’ 100-acre fenced deer-hunting operation over safety fears; a November 20 appeals court ruled it is a recreational preserve that needs a special zoning permit

Balen Shah’s India visit: What’s on the agenda as Nepal PM makes first official trip | India News

Balen Shah’s India visit: What’s on the agenda as Nepal PM makes first official trip | India News

Dynamic Country URL Go to Country Info Page