Debuting on Broadway 66 years after its premiere, the “Fantasticks” revival that just opened at the Helen Hayes Theater throws a defiant challenge.
Luisa and Matt, the wide-eyed young lovers in Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s endearing, enduring musical, are now both male: Lewis (Nathan Levy) and Matt (Maxim Chlumecky).
Yet, beside the trend of gender-swapping in classic musicals (a lesbian pairing in “Oklahoma!” here, a female Bobbie in “Company” there), it’s hard to find a place more tolerant of queerness than Broadway. The gleefully pansexual “Rocky Horror Show” is running just a few blocks away. A gay couple onstage is not going to make anyone in a New York City audience clutch his pearls.
Even within the world of the show — in which the conspiring fathers have been replaced by meddling mothers — nobody bats an eyelash.
“Two boys?” the narrator and trickster El Gallo (Zane Phillips) asks. “And you’re not worried?”
Lewis’s mom, Bessie (Ruthie Ann Miles), is unbothered: “They love each other. Why should we be worried?”
But the real reason this Second Stage production of “The Fantasticks,” directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli, is such an outlier among current Broadway musicals is that it is bereft of the slightest hint of sarcasm, power belting or video trickery. The show basks in quaintness and the magic of traditional theater-making, with its supporting players, expertly portrayed by David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila, forming a kind of connective tissue to Shakespeare and vaudeville.
The links to the sensibility of the original — a perennial favorite on the school and amateur circuits — are everywhere, helping make this an actually faithful revisal. Jones himself retooled his book and lyrics after the director Michael Lluberes suggested having two young men as the romantic leads for a production at the Flint Repertory Theater in 2022, and others have since used the same-sex setup. (Jones died in 2023.) And the staging concepts that have long accompanied “The Fantasticks” are intact, like a highly stylized scenic design (here by Jason Sherwood) and a wall embodied by a whimsical mime character called the Mute (Ahmad Simmons).
Gattelli even opens with winks to the original production: a piano and a harp sit onstage as a nod to the two instruments of the initial score, and the wheeled trunk marked Sullivan Street Playhouse is a reference to the venue where “The Fantasticks” surfaced in 1960, back when Greenwich Village could nurture a whimsical chamber musical. (A 1964 televised adaptation, starring Ricardo Montalban as El Gallo, captured a sense of what it was like to discover the show a few years after it premiered.)
For this production, the music director and orchestrator Sam Davis has expanded the sparse original arrangements to eight instruments, but he preserved Schmidt’s delicate inventiveness and his unerring melodic sense — the buoyant “I Can See It” recalls Leonard Bernstein’s musical-theater compositions (there is even a quick “West Side Story” joke a little later) and at times the score brings to mind Jerome Moross’s adventurous “The Golden Apple” (1954), another oddball musical that started Off Broadway.
Act I hits all its marks here, deftly balancing tenderness, sweetness and humor. The comic chops of Miles and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, who plays Matt’s mother, are an invaluable asset in that last regard — I wish I could watch their “Never Say No” on repeat — and their welcome earthiness counterbalances their sons’ dreamy courtship.
Chlumecky and Levy neatly delineate their characters, Lewis the fiery dreamer proclaiming “I am special!” and Matt the practical one. And while convincingly playing young love, especially as idealized and swoony as it is depicted in Act I, is tough, the actors have a radiant warmth together. Their duet “Soon It’s Gonna Rain” is particularly beautiful.
So all’s well that ends well for our lovers, their mothers and the story … until intermission hits. Because as El Gallo foreshadowed in “Try to Remember,” the show’s first number and its eternal hit: “Without a hurt / The heart is hollow.” True love must be tested, and when everybody returns for Act II, El Gallo takes it upon himself to teach that.
We kick back into action with the swinging “This Plum Is Too Ripe,” but the production then starts spinning its wheels. Partly this is a factory setting, as Jones’s book summons disputes and dramatic declarations out of thin air to kick-start his point about the disappointments brought on when romantic fantasy runs into reality. The grandness does not sound as natural anymore. “I’ll drink and gamble!” Matt says, announcing he’s taking off on an adventure. “I’ll grow a mustache!”
Lewis matches him: “I’ll have an affair!” he retorts.
Gattelli, so at ease earlier, does not have a solution for the tonal changes. Or maybe he does not want to fully engage with them and what they might look like, especially when Lewis and El Gallo grow close.
He is also hampered by the fact that El Gallo slips out of Phillips’s grasp as the show goes on and the character moves from Cupid’s little helper to manipulative schemer. The actor’s muscular physique — he looks ready to star as Jack Reacher’s long-lost brother — is made even more distracting by a carnival-strongman costume that is the designer Linda Cho’s single faux pas. El Gallo needs to act a little bit dashing but also a little bit dastardly; Philipps (who does acquit himself well in the musical numbers) does not quite fulfill either.
Like many beloved musicals, “The Fantasticks” is about romance but also about theater and artifice. The comedown from heightened emotions implies accepting a measure of reality. As El Gallo warns at the top of Act II, “What was last night scenic / May seem cynic by today.” And just like our lovers had to toughen up, maybe “The Fantasticks” did need a little of that new Broadway spirit after all.
The Fantasticks
Through Feb. 7 at the Helen Hayes Theater, Manhattan; fantasticksbroadway.com. Running time: 2 hours 5 minutes.