A write-in vote can be invalid and still tell us something. Why hide the names?

Acton - Brown campaign rally, Oct. 24, 2026
November 16, 2026

LATEST NEWS

A write-in vote can be invalid and still tell us something. Why hide the names?

Taking the time to write someone’s name on a ballot says something, even when that vote cannot count toward electing anyone. Why should the public lose the chance to find out what thousands of Cuyahoga County voters were trying to say?

That’s the question host Chris Quinn raised Monday on Today in Ohio after host Lisa Garvin described more than 5,000 write-in choices for county executive that would remain unknown. Hosts Leila Atassi and Laura Johnston joined him in questioning why names they remembered being able to see after earlier elections were now unavailable.

Quinn noted the difference between counting a vote and letting people inspect it. Election officials could reject a write-in for purposes of the official result, he argued, while still showing the public what the voter wrote.

“I think if people go into a ballot booth and take the time to mark someone else and write in the name, you don’t have to count it, but you should make it available,” he said.

Garvin said about 5,700 voters had written in someone other than County Executive Chris Ronayne, whi was unopposed. Only about 10% of those votes counted: 580 cast for the registered write-in candidate.

The rest left the hosts with a question they could not answer: Whose names had those voters supplied?

Garvin explained the counting rules as described by Board of Elections spokesman Mike West. A voter must fill in the write-in oval and name a registered write-in candidate. A partial name can qualify, but a name that is too vague, or one belonging to an unregistered candidate, does not count.

Mickey Mouse and Donald Duck were the familiar examples. Quinn’s objection was that the public was being denied the opportunity to see the actual choices, humorous or otherwise.

“That’s a public record,” he said. “That’s an action of a voter that we should all see for posterity. It should be preserved.”

He proposed making images of the write-in fields available so people could examine them for themselves. In his view, the scanning of ballots should make that possible without requiring election officials to tally every unregistered name.

“I think this is about as anti-democratic as it gets,” he said.

The other hosts recalled a time when write-ins supplied a regular postelection story. Atassi remembered being able to access the names. Garvin agreed. Johnston recalled being able to see how many votes Mickey Mouse received.

Garvin’s figures suggested more was going on than a few people amusing themselves with cartoon characters. She said the executive contest drew more than twice as many write-ins as all the other races combined. About 170,000 voters, roughly a third, skipped the contest altogether.

She noted that voters often bypass a race with no competitive choice because they expect the result is already settled. But the write-in total caught her attention.

“So you can see maybe a little undercurrent of unhappiness there,” Garvin said.

She also supplied one name the public otherwise would not know: She had written in Quinn.

“So you got at least one vote for county executive,” she told him.

Johnston said a headline referring to the other Chris in the race had briefly made her think of Quinn, too. The exchange produced a detour into joking about his unexpected candidacy, but Quinn returned to the transparency question.

He wanted to know whether a legal restriction prevented disclosure or whether election officials simply were unwilling to make the information available.

Quinn also challenged the requirement that write-in candidates register, saying it defeated the purpose of allowing voters to supply a name.

“We should know who they wrote in,” he said. “It could be very telling about what’s on people’s minds.”

Listen to the conversation here.

Listen to full “Today in Ohio” episodes where Chris Quinn hosts our daily half-hour news podcast, with Editorial Board member Lisa Garvin, Impact Editor Leila Atassi and Content Director Laura Johnston.

Share this post:

POLL

Who Will Vote For?

Other

Republican

Democrat

RECENT NEWS

Charred green beans with olive-herb relish

Charred green beans with olive-herb relish

Trump administration moves to auction Pacific seabed near American Samoa

Trump administration moves to auction Pacific seabed near American Samoa

Kuku paka chicken burgers

Kuku paka chicken burgers

Dynamic Country URL Go to Country Info Page