Yankees detail postseason rotation decisions that could include surprise

Mostly Sunny
September 19, 2025

LATEST NEWS

Yankees detail postseason rotation decisions that could include surprise

BALTIMORE — Almost home free to a playoff spot, the Yankees know who they want starting the first two games if they’re in a best-of-three Wild Card Series.

They want Max Fried pitching Game 1, then Carlos Rodon pitching Game 2. They currently have rookie right-hander Will Warren between the All-Star left-handers, but that will change for the playoffs.

Fried already is lined up to pitch the playoff opener on regular four days’ rest with Rodon positioned to pitch the next game on an extra day.

“You want the two best pitchers going,” pitching coach Matt Blake told NJ Advance Media prior to Thursday night’s 7-0 win over the Orioles. “I don’t know if there’s a real benefit of splitting them up.

“If those are the two main guys, if you split them up and put a righty in the middle, you run the risk of one of them not pitching in a wild-card scenario.”

The majors’ wins leader, Fried is 18-5 in 31 starts with a 2.92 ERA that is fifth best in the AL after working seven scoreless innings in Thursday night’s 7-0 win over the Orioles.

Rodon, who has two remaining starts, is 16-9 with a 3.11 ERA in 31 outings.

The Yankees have been holding off on making a final decision because they still have to clinch a postseason berth. They’re in great shape now sitting in the first wild card spot with a 4 ½-game lead over the first team out. And even though the Blue Jays will go into the weekend leading the AL East by three games and hold the tiebreaker, the Yankees still have nine games to close the gap, all of them against last-place teams.

Just in case, the Yankees have been open to starting Fried on regular rest twice next week at Yankee Stadium, Tuesday against the White Sox and then Sunday against the Orioles if and only if they needed to win their season finale to get in.

But with the Yankees now in great shape to at least get a wild card, a decision probably will be made this weekend to keep the rotation in turn for the rest of the season. That would have Will Warren starting next Tuesday and Sunday with Fried making a final regular-season start on Wednesday and then pitching the first playoff game.

“That’s definitely a conversation we’ve got to have the next couple days,” Blake said. “Are we going to push to have Max Fried available for that last game or not?”

Probably not.

“I don’t necessarily anticipate us doing that,” manager Aaron Boone said. “We’re going to keep them on their normal turn and try to win every day.”

If the Yankees steal the division, they’d have five days before beginning a best-of-five Division Series on Saturday, Oct. 4. That would have Fried pitching Game 1 on nine days rest and Rodon starting Game 2 on eight days’ rest from his regular-season finale, which is scheduled for next Friday.

That’s not ideal, but the Yankees obviously would love to avoid a best-of-three series even though the first wild card has home-field advantage for every game.

What’s undecided is who would start a do-or-die Game 3 if a Wild Card Series goes the distance. At this point, rookie Cam Schlittler appears to be the favorite to get the nod over Luis Gil with Warren a possibility to make the postseason roster as a reliever.

Schlittler (3-3, 3.41 ERA) has been good to excellent for most of his eight starts since being called up from Triple-A on July 9 to debut. Gil (4-1, 3.33) has 29 walks in 46 innings over nine starts since returning from a spring training late strain in early August.

Warren (8-7, 4.44 ERA) deserves consideration, too. He’s allowed two or fewer runs in 21 of his 31 starts and his ERA drops to 3.68 if you wipe out two starts in which he allowed a total of 15 runs over 5.1 innings.

“I think Schlittler is really good and he’s not afraid,” Boone said. “Luis is still kind of searching for it, but he’s finding a way. Warren has had a lot of good starts.”

If the Yankees win a Wild Card Series, they’ll go with four starters for their Division Series with Fried lined up to pitch the second and fifth games on regular rest.

Warren could be play here, but Schlittler and Gil likely would be the choices to join Fried and Rodon.

“I think all three of them have their strengths that you can point to for why they should be the third starter,” Blake said. “All three of them have warts, too, whether it’s lack of experience or tough outings. But I think all three would give you a chance to win.

“It’s just a matter of what’s the best composition for who you’re playing and potentially who would help in the bullpen.”

The Yankees’ rotation has been one of the best in the majors this season. Its 3.68 ERA ranks fourth behind only the Rangers (3.39), Brewers (3.52) and Phillies (3.68).

The starters have been on a roll since Aug. 19 with a 2.82 ERA in 29 games, 17 of them outings lasting at least six innings.

“It’s probably as good as we’ve been all year, this last month or so, with five guys taking the turn and give us a chance to win,” Blake said. “Obviously there’s been a blip here and there, but on the whole the work’s been really good getting us through five and a lot of times six and turning it over with the lead.

“We’re happy about that.”

The rotation has been so consistent lately that Blake joked former Cy Young winner Gerrit Cole might have to earn a spot when he returns next summer from Tommy John surgery.

“No guarantees around here,” Blake said with a laugh.

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Share this post:

POLL

Who Will Vote For?

Other

Republican

Democrat

RECENT NEWS

New York Area Codes That Have Most Scam Callers

New York Area Codes That Have Most Scam Callers

Mostly Sunny

Brownlee leads Egg Harbor Township past Mainland – Girls soccer recap

NJ high school athletes nominated for Heart of a Giant Award

NJ high school athletes nominated for Heart of a Giant Award

Dynamic Country URL Go to Country Info Page